Skip to main content

EEE330 — Further reading

One optional paper for each lecture, with what to focus on and what to skip

Optional papers for each lecture of EEE330 Population Ecology, with what to focus on and what to skip.

Each lecture ends with a Further reading slide: one optional paper, with what to focus on and what to skip. Read it in the free hour after the lecture, in the evening, or after the course; none of it is examined. Where a part you skip now is taught in a later lecture, Later says when to come back to it. The PDFs are on OLAT.

L1 — Population ecology through the Florida panther

Pimm, Dollar and Bass (2006), with the reply by Creel (2006), Animal Conservation 9. Read the two together (about 8 pages): a claim and its critique. Focus: Pimm’s Fig. 1 (deaths by sex and origin) and the passage on kittens that die anyway; Creel’s alternative, “demographic rescue”. Skip: Pimm’s Methods paragraph on data sources and Table 1. Creel’s “fig. 2a and b” means Pimm’s Fig. 1. AIC is a score for comparing models: lower is better.

L2 — Life histories

Daan, Deerenberg and Dijkstra (1996), Journal of Animal Ecology: kestrels with enlarged and reduced broods (5 pages). Focus: the Introduction (why lower local survival could mean death or leaving), Table 1 (the manipulation worked), Fig. 1 (survival by treatment). Skip: the deviance tables (Table 3). Fig. 2 (deaths by season) has no symbol key: read it with the text. Later: after L10, the Introduction again: local survival is apparent survival, death and emigration combined.

L3 — Life cycles and matrices

Hunter et al. (2010), Ecology: polar bears and sea ice. First half only. Focus: the Introduction, “Demographic model structure” and the deterministic results (pp. 2883–2888); Fig. 2 (the life cycle) with Appendix A (the matrix written in vital rates); Fig. 3. Skip: the bootstrap, the LTRE, the stochastic model and the sea-ice forecasts. Later: the LTRE after L5 (which rates make poor-ice years worse); the stochastic model and Fig. 5 after L6.

L4 — Growth, structure and transients

Crouse, Crowder and Caswell (1987), Ecology: loggerhead sea turtles. Focus: from life table (Table 3) to matrix (Table 4), then λ, stable stage distribution and reproductive value (Table 5); Fig. 1. Skip: the formulas for P and G (they assume λ = 1). Later: the elasticity figures (Figs 3–4) after L5.

L5 — Sensitivity, elasticity and LTRE

Crowder et al. (1994), Ecological Applications: turtle excluder devices. Focus: Fig. 2 (elasticities), Fig. 4 (cutting mortality at each stage), Fig. 6 (transient waves of nesting females). Skip: the appendices.

L6 — Variable environments

Gaillard, Festa-Bianchet and Yoccoz (1998), Trends in Ecology & Evolution: variable recruitment, constant adult survival (5 pages). Focus: Fig. 1 (bighorn juvenile and adult survival over 20 years), Tables 2 and 3 (how much each rate varies), Box 1 (elasticity, as in L5). Skip: nothing; Box 2 is optional. Later: Box 2 (sampling vs true variation) after L10.

L7 — Density dependence and drivers

Wiens et al. (2021), PNAS: removing barred owls. Focus: the Significance statement, the Introduction, the Results and Fig. 3 (survival, recruitment and λ in removal and control areas). Skip: Materials and Methods. Note that this is competition between species, not density dependence within one. Later: Materials and Methods after L10 (multistate capture–recapture).

L8 — Harvest

Servanty et al. (2011), Journal of Applied Ecology: wild boar under light and heavy hunting. Focus: Fig. 2 (age pyramids), Fig. 5 (which age class to harvest), Table 3 (boar among ungulates). Also read: “Matrix perturbation analysis” and “Retrospective analysis”: after L5 you have the tools (elasticity, LTRE). Skip: the test statistics at the start of the Results. Keep in mind: only two populations, which differ in more than hunting.

Papers for L9–L11 follow.