EEE330 — Further reading
One optional paper for each lecture, with what to focus on and what to skip
Each lecture ends with a Further reading slide: one optional paper, with what to focus on and what to skip. Read it in the free hour after the lecture, in the evening, or after the course; none of it is examined. Where a part you skip now is taught in a later lecture, Later says when to come back to it. The PDFs are on OLAT.
L1 — Population ecology through the Florida panther
Pimm, Dollar and Bass (2006), with the reply by Creel (2006), Animal Conservation 9. Read the two together (about 8 pages): a claim and its critique. Focus: Pimm’s Fig. 1 (deaths by sex and origin) and the passage on kittens that die anyway; Creel’s alternative, “demographic rescue”. Skip: Pimm’s Methods paragraph on data sources and Table 1. Creel’s “fig. 2a and b” means Pimm’s Fig. 1. AIC is a score for comparing models: lower is better.
L2 — Life histories
Daan, Deerenberg and Dijkstra (1996), Journal of Animal Ecology: kestrels with enlarged and reduced broods (5 pages). Focus: the Introduction (why lower local survival could mean death or leaving), Table 1 (the manipulation worked), Fig. 1 (survival by treatment). Skip: the deviance tables (Table 3). Fig. 2 (deaths by season) has no symbol key: read it with the text. Later: after L10, the Introduction again: local survival is apparent survival, death and emigration combined.
L3 — Life cycles and matrices
Hunter et al. (2010), Ecology: polar bears and sea ice. First half only. Focus: the Introduction, “Demographic model structure” and the deterministic results (pp. 2883–2888); Fig. 2 (the life cycle) with Appendix A (the matrix written in vital rates); Fig. 3. Skip: the bootstrap, the LTRE, the stochastic model and the sea-ice forecasts. Later: the LTRE after L5 (which rates make poor-ice years worse); the stochastic model and Fig. 5 after L6.
L4 — Growth, structure and transients
Crouse, Crowder and Caswell (1987), Ecology: loggerhead sea turtles. Focus: from life table (Table 3) to matrix (Table 4), then λ, stable stage distribution and reproductive value (Table 5); Fig. 1. Skip: the formulas for P and G (they assume λ = 1). Later: the elasticity figures (Figs 3–4) after L5.
L5 — Sensitivity, elasticity and LTRE
Crowder et al. (1994), Ecological Applications: turtle excluder devices. Focus: Fig. 2 (elasticities), Fig. 4 (cutting mortality at each stage), Fig. 6 (transient waves of nesting females). Skip: the appendices.
L6 — Variable environments
Gaillard, Festa-Bianchet and Yoccoz (1998), Trends in Ecology & Evolution: variable recruitment, constant adult survival (5 pages). Focus: Fig. 1 (bighorn juvenile and adult survival over 20 years), Tables 2 and 3 (how much each rate varies), Box 1 (elasticity, as in L5). Skip: nothing; Box 2 is optional. Later: Box 2 (sampling vs true variation) after L10.
L7 — Density dependence and drivers
Wiens et al. (2021), PNAS: removing barred owls. Focus: the Significance statement, the Introduction, the Results and Fig. 3 (survival, recruitment and λ in removal and control areas). Skip: Materials and Methods. Note that this is competition between species, not density dependence within one. Later: Materials and Methods after L10 (multistate capture–recapture).
L8 — Harvest
Servanty et al. (2011), Journal of Applied Ecology: wild boar under light and heavy hunting. Focus: Fig. 2 (age pyramids), Fig. 5 (which age class to harvest), Table 3 (boar among ungulates). Also read: “Matrix perturbation analysis” and “Retrospective analysis”: after L5 you have the tools (elasticity, LTRE). Skip: the test statistics at the start of the Results. Keep in mind: only two populations, which differ in more than hunting.
Papers for L9–L11 follow.